Only Murders in the Building Wiki
Only Murders in the Building Wiki

Mikey Caccimelio is a recurring character in Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building.

He is portrayed by Cory Jeacoma.

History[]

Mikey and his brothers started a podcast called Ey, I'm Talkin' Here! about historical mob stories. When Charles-Haden Savage, Mabel Mora, and Oliver Putnam showed up at their house, they invited the trio inside, believing they were there to do a collaboration for their podcast. They showed off their gun/bluetooth speaker, scaring the trio who thought it was a real gun. When Johnny accidentally spilled the cup they had brought, which had a human finger in it, the brothers were all scared and begged the trio not to hurt them. They explained what they were doing. When their mother came home, she sent them out of the room so she could talk to the trio.[2]

Mikey and his brothers came to a Hibachi restaurant with their mother to celebrate Mikey's 36th birthday. When she met up with Charles there and decided to take him home with her, she left her sons to make their own way home on the bus, reminding them to stick together. When they said they wanted to play Fortnite, she reminded them they were taking a break from screens.[3]

Mikey and his brothers were at the dry cleaners with Nonna when Teddy, Mabel, Charles, and Oliver came in to confront them about the finger, which Nonna had stolen from Charles' freezer.[4] They tried to stop them from questioning Nonna, but then Howard flirted with Vinny, who agreed to show Howard the starching machine, taking the brothers away from the counter.

The brothers then came to the Arconia to intimidate the billionaires while Mabel, Charles, and Oliver confronted them. However, after they realized they were hurting more than helping, the trio sent them out.

Three months later, Mikey and his brothers called their mother, who was in Italy, to tell her that Nonna was dying. Sofia talked to Nonna on the phone and she took her last breath.[5]

Relationships[]

Notes and Trivia[]

  • His address is: 110 Longbellow Avenue, Staten Island, NY.[2]
  • Has a podcast alongside his brothers, called, 'Ey, I'm Talkin' Here!', where they talk about historical mob stories.[2]

Gallery[]

Episode Stills[]

Appearances[]

List of Characters
MAIN Charles-Haden SavageOliver PutnamMabel MoraHoward MorrisJan BellowsOscar Torres
RECURRING Tim KonoDonna WilliamsSazz PatakiTeddy DimasTheo DimasZoe CassidyUrsulaCinda CanningUma HellerArnav KapoorBunny FolgerLester ColucaPoppy WhiteNdidi IdokoGrover StanleyAmy HuangWill PutnamSamPauletteMarvAlice BanksDaniel KrepsJoy PayneLucyBen GlenroyBobo MaloneCliff DeMeoDickie GlenroyDonna DeMeoJonathan BridgecroftKimber MinK.T. KnoblauerLoretta DurkinTobertEugene LevyEva LongoriaZach GalifianakisMarshall P. PopeVince FishRudy ThurberMilton DudenoffGlen StubbinsBev MelonMayor Beau TillmanLorraine ColucaRandall WinstonSofia CaccimelioNicky CaccimelioJohnny CaccimelioAltheaBash SteedCamila WhiteJay PflugMiller Portnoy
GUEST StingRoberta PutnamJosé TorresJimmy FallonSilvia MoraKiaraAmy SchumerMatthew BroderickScott BakulaDoreenRon HowardRomyTony CaccimelioMikey CaccimelioVinny CaccimelioBraden CaccimelioNonnaGeorgeMrs. MorrisLindaRonAlgernon


References[]

  1. "Tongue Tied" (2025): Season 5, Episode 5. Sofia mentions that it's Mickey's 36th birthday in a particular scene. In another scene, Oliver mentions that it's five months after December of the previous year and seven months before the next December.
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 "Nail in the Coffin" (2025). Season 5, episode 1.
  3. "Tongue Tied" (2025). Season 5, episode 5.
  4. "LESTR" (2025). Season 5, episode 9.
  5. "The House Always..." (2025). Season 5, episode 10.